Sunday, 09 May, 2021


Congress challenges Vice Prez rejection of impeachment move against CJI

Governance       Venkaiah Naidu’s rejection of CJI impeachment motion politically motivated 2 Congress MPs
       
       	        Maneesh Chhibber         7 May 2018 Governance Venkaiah Naidu’s rejection of CJI impeachment motion politically motivated 2 Congress MPs Maneesh Chhibber 7 May 2018
Bennie Garza | 07 May, 2018, 12:48

Chelameshwar asked Sibal to return with the petition on Tuesday. "It deserves to be set aside for being wholly extraneous and ultra vires to the provisions of the Constitution of India and the Inquiry Act", stated the petition filed through advocate Sunil Fernandes.

Two Congress MPs from Rajya Sabha - Pratap Singh Bajwa and Amee Harshadray Yajnik filed a petition in the apex court challenging Naidu's decision.

"...it is not the Chairman's prerogative to adjudicate whether there has been any abuse by the Hon'ble CJI of his power as the Master of the Roster".

The petition said the removal was rejected despite "clear, tenable and cogent charges" and the Chairman did not form a three-member inquiry committee as contemplated under Section 3 (2) of the Judges Inquiry Act. He also held deliberations with senior officials of the Rajya Sabha Secretariat, they said, adding that Naidu also spoke to former Supreme Court judge B Sudarshan Reddy.

The Congress MPs' plea said: "The impugned order proceeds on an erroneous assumption in law that the chairman/speaker, exercises quasi-judicial powers to determine whether to admit or not to admit a notice of motion and whether to constitute the aforesaid committee". The petition said the Rajya Sabha chairperson only holds discretion if the motion does not have the required number of signatures.

It is contended that this provision pertains to the genuineness and authenticity of the signatures to the Notice of Motion, and can not extend to going into the merits of the motion.

Another point made in the petition is that Naidu had quoted extensively on the minority judgment in M Krishna Swami v. Union of India to buttress his point.

"It is unusual that when the motion related to the impeachment of the Chief Justice, the chairman deemed it fit to consult legal luminaries, constitutional experts, former secretary generals, former law officers, Law Commission members and eminent jurists but had not thought it appropriate and fit to consult the judges of the Supreme Court of India".

The appeal says that the Vice-President's decision was "illegal and arbitrary".

It further alleges that the Chairman's order was based on political considerations.

The Congress had also asserted that while the constitutional process of removal is set in motion with 50 MPs giving agreement, the removal notice of the Chief Justice of India was agreed to by as many as 64 MPs.

Seven opposition parties led by the Congress had in April third week moved a notice before the Chairman for impeachment of the CJI on five grounds of "misbehaviour".

Recommended

loading...
...
  • 6 SORE MUSCLES EASING REMEDIES THAT TRAINERS RELY ON

    Although no one enjoys the pain of muscle tears, many people find the final result worth the discomfort they experience. He then recommended that you should follow it up with low-intensity cardio routines, or a simple yoga session.
    Jio is providing interestingly 1.1 TB free data

    Jio is providing interestingly 1.1 TB free data

    The Mukesh Ambani-led Reliance Jio has plans to launch the service for both households and commercial customers. It unclear if the remaining 1TB of data will be made available at the same 100Mbps speed.
    The 10 best football players in the world

    The 10 best football players in the world

    But even so, there’s no denying that he has impressive skills and he managed to lead all his football teams to big titles. Now at PSG, there are a lot of rumors that he might come back in Spain to play for life-time rivals of Barcelona, Real Madrid.
  • When to Consult a Tax Professional

    When to Consult a Tax Professional

    Typically, capital transactions are actually taxed at lower rates than standard income, but holding assets can get complicated. If you take care of someone financially or have children, definitely check with a professional tax preparer or accountant.
    Instagram quietly launches payments for commerce

    Instagram quietly launches payments for commerce

    We can expect users shopping more via Instagram, as this payments feature allows users shop without the need of leaving the app. Users, on WhatsApp, could transfer money to other contacts and even pay for goods and services to make purchase offline.
    Coli outbreak linked to romaine lettuce in the US

    Coli outbreak linked to romaine lettuce in the US

    More than a dozen locations are under scrutiny for possible links to the cases, according to the Food and Drug Administration. But even if no one is eating tainted lettuce now, case counts may still rise because there's a lag in reporting.
  • Kanye's Tweets Get Everyone Killed In SNL's A Quiet Place Parody

    Kanye's Tweets Get Everyone Killed In SNL's A Quiet Place Parody

    Eventually, everyone gets eaten except for Glover, who is left to listen to Kanye's nonsensical lyrics on his new song, " Lift Yourself ".
    North Korean foreign ministry blasts USA  pressure claims

    North Korean foreign ministry blasts USA pressure claims

    Several US senators have even called for the president to win a Nobel Peace prize for his role in the Inter-Korean Summit. North Korea has criticized the USA and Japan for using pressure to achieve the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula.

    How to learn English with the news

    Your main purpose is to master or improve your language skills, so it is not so big deal if you listen to or read something fake. How to learn English through the news It is undeniable that the news is a great source of the words that are used everywhere.
  • SC strikes down UP law allowing ex-CMs to keep government house

    SC strikes down UP law allowing ex-CMs to keep government house

    That judgment was delivered by a Bench of Justices Anil R Dave , NV Ramana and R Banumathi in a petition filed in by the same NGO, Lok Prahari.
    This WhatsApp message can crash your phone

    This WhatsApp message can crash your phone

    This is not a hoax as numerous WhatsApp users on Android are reporting that their app is crashing after they tap on the black dot. While there is nothing malicious behind this bug but has seemingly been created to plague you.

    Tiger Woods, Phil Mickelson Grouped Together at Players Championship

    The longtime rivals on tour have not been paired in any PGA Tour event since the PGA Championship four years ago. Woods, 42, and Mickelson, 47, have combined to win 19 major championships and a total of 122 PGA Tour titles.

Overdosing Nicotine: Should You Be Concerned? A lot of effort has been made to educate the public on the dangers of smoking, but most of the time, it has yielded no fruits. Symptoms of Nicotine Symptoms Though you may not get poisoned from vaping, one way or another, e-liquid may get to your skin.

Top Reasons to Consider a Tax Advisor for your Business Top Reasons to Consider a Tax Advisor for your Business Tax advisors can also help to provide you with educated business advice, asset management, and discuss retirement plans with you. Hiring a tax accountant allows you to spend more of your precious time on your business, rather than worrying over your taxes.

A DETAILED GUIDE ON ESCAPE HOUR A DETAILED GUIDE ON ESCAPE HOUR Mental health Generally, once you get into these escape rooms, you don’t get out the way you were before you got in. Getting unstuck from a rut If you are always too engulfed in your routine, one day you will want to do something different.

Arzani, Karacic named in Socceroos' initial squad Arzani, Karacic named in Socceroos' initial squad The 26 man squad will travel to Turkey for pre-tournament training camp and then play friendlies in Austria and Hungary. His selection, Van Marwijk said, could provide a solution to the problematic right-back position.

Apple acknowledges mic issue in these iPhones after iOS 11.3 update Apple acknowledges mic issue in these iPhones after iOS 11.3 update If a customer's phone is not under warranty the Apple authorised service provider can request an exception due to this bug. Apparently, as noted by users, when the rear camera of the iPhone X fails to work, Face ID ends up not working too.

Nunes wants to hold Sessions in contempt of Congress Nunes wants to hold Sessions in contempt of Congress Ellis III, who said in a Virginia Federal Court Friday, "we don't want anyone in this country with unfettered power". Nunes was denied access to classified information from the Justice Department that he says is 'very important'.

Watch Childish Gambino Debut Another New Song, 'Saturday', On Saturday Night Live Watch Childish Gambino Debut Another New Song, 'Saturday', On Saturday Night Live Today, Glover is also known for his acclaimed FX series Atlanta , which earned him a Golden Globe and two Emmys past year . Glover stars as Lando Calrissian in the highly anticipated film Solo: A Star Wars Story , in theaters Friday, May 25.

Plot to assassinate Mahumapelo uncovered, says his office Plot to assassinate Mahumapelo uncovered, says his office There are also jitters about a possible backlash from Mahumapelo's supporters. More pressure is being piled on Mahumapelo from outside the ANC.

Cybersecurity uncharted territory, risks to get worse: Warren Buffett Cybersecurity uncharted territory, risks to get worse: Warren Buffett This year seemed "a little bit more awkward and uncomfortable in the morning than I've experienced in the past". Usually, global fund managers looking to invest in emerging markets talk of China and India in the same breath.

Woman Allegedly Blows Up Pee Sample In A 7-Eleven Microwave Woman Allegedly Blows Up Pee Sample In A 7-Eleven Microwave Aurora Police said Sanchez told them the substance was not real urine, and she didn't understand why police were called. Sanchez has been arrested a number of times and convicted of theft, according to a Colorado criminal background check.

Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited (TEVA) EPS Estimated At $0.62 The stock has a market capitalization of $17,968.22, a price-to-earnings ratio of 4.54, a PEG ratio of 1.54 and a beta of 0.67. The company reported $0.91 earnings per share (EPS) for the quarter, topping the Zacks' consensus estimate of $0.63 by $0.28.

Salman Khan to plead for leniency on antelope killing charge Salman Khan to plead for leniency on antelope killing charge The accused were charged with hunting and killing two blackbucks, which are protected animals under the Wildlife Protection Act. Snapped at the Mumbai airport this morning, Salman was seen looking his handsome best as he headed to Jodhpur .

Juve almost certain to win title after Napoli stalemate Juve almost certain to win title after Napoli stalemate Inter assured fifth place and seal at least Europa League action next season while keeping their Champions League challenge alive. Inter moved two points behind fourth-placed Lazio who were held 1-1 at home by Atalanta.

JPMorgan Chase Analysts Set Live Nation Entertainment (LYV) a $51.00 Target Price It has outperformed by 30.24% the S&P500.The move comes after 7 months positive chart setup for the $9.35B company. The forecast of 6 surveyed investment analysts covering the stock advises investors to Buy stake in the company.

Latest News on the Global Online Gaming Industry The company is showing signs of making a comeback, as competitors are forced to merge and consolidate in order to survive. The industry can be broken down further between mobile gambling and desktop gambling (which includes laptops and PCs).