Kennedy Is Key to Supreme Court Outcome on Partisan Maps
Kennedy Is Key to Supreme Court Outcome on Partisan Maps
Outside of the Supreme Court building in D.C. people gather for the #FairMaps rally. Lauryn Gutierrez Rewire
04 October, 2017, 01:14
The justices will take a close look at Wisconsin, where Republicans drew an electoral map after the last census that was created to ensure they would retain a 60-vote supermajority in the state Assembly even if a majority of the state's voters chose Democrats.
Throughout the session, the justices and lawyers alike appeared to cast their questions and remarks with the hope of attracting Kennedy. The court will decide all three by June. The effects of gerrymandering and the voter suppression laws have been amplified by supposed "strict constructionists" construing the First Amendment guarantee of free speech so loosely as to strike down laws governing campaign financing. Early in the argument, Kennedy appeared to signal that he thought partisan gerrymanders violate the First Amendment, a view he also hinted at in a 2004 opinion. For example, according to Justice Kennedy, employees can hire the same lawyer, advance the same evidence, and collaborate in the prosecution of their claims. Justice Clarence Thomas asked no questions but he is expected to side with the conservatives.
The case concerns the map approved in 2011 for the Wisconsin Assembly.
If the court opens the door to partisan challenges, he said, "every one of these cases will come here".
Kennedy suggested that courts could be involved in placing limits on extremely partisan electoral maps. They said repeatedly that it was the Obama administration's labor board that changed sides when it held for the first time in 2012 that mandatory individual arbitration provisions abridge employees' rights to act in concert. The yield, for Republicans in the U.S. House of Representatives, was as many as twenty-two additional seats-enough of a surplus to account for nearly all of the G.O.P.'s advantage in the chamber.
After winning control of the state legislature in 2010, Wisconsin Republicans redrew the maps for the state assembly to their considerable benefit.
The heightened Democratic focus on state legislatures will be tested this fall in Virginia, where the party will try to chip away at the GOP's almost 2-to-1 state assembly majority, and Nevada, where Republicans are pushing to recall several sitting Democrats in a bid to change party control of the state Senate.
This wasn't just a problem in Wisconsin. The plaintiffs in the case are average Wisconsin citizens who believe deeply in democracy and believe that the right to vote is a right worth fighting for. The result was that Republicans had a virtual lock on four times as many state legislative and US House seats as Democrats did. They have concocted an "efficiency index", showing that the state's district lines leave many more Democratic than Republican voters with legislators they oppose.
The U.S. Supreme Court today heard oral arguments in Gill v. Whitford, a case that challenges Wisconsin electoral maps on partisan gerrymandering grounds.
"It's a fixed system - that's what gerrymandering is all about", he said.
State and federal legislative district boundaries are reconfigured after the US government conducts a census every decade to make each one contain about same number of people. Sheldon Whitehouse said in a Supreme Court brief. Now that Justice Neil Gorsuch has joined the court he will presumably break a tie. Justices Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor quickly countered that partisan map-drawers rely on advanced social sciences and technology as a matter of course, and that Wisconsin's drawers had used such methods to create the most partisan map possible. Moreover, the composition of the court that is now deliberating on the gerrymandering case is itself the product of an extra-constitutional exercise of power by a Senate majority that refused to perform its constitutional duty of considering a nomination by the then-incumbent president. The group includes some people facing deportation because they've committed a crime and others who arrived at the border seeking asylum.
He pressed the state's lawyers about whether it would be unconstitutional for the state to simply declare that it was going to favor one party over another.
"I suspect that that's manageable", Breyer said. It also triggered an especially passionate response from liberal Justice Stephen Breyer. The Framers pointed us in that direction, not toward entrusting (sometimes partisan) judges with the impossible task of eliminating partisanship from politics. "It worked", she said, referring to Republicans' huge legislative majorities. They worked in secret to fashion precise, computer-generated maps and won approval on a party-line vote. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg asked. "What's really behind all of this?"
"What incentive is there for a voter to exercise his vote?"
Saban, not surprisingly, added that there is still plenty to improve on, citing dropped passes and seven penalties for 60 yards. Obviously, the 5-0 team dominated the Rebels (2-2) on all aspects of play, outgaining Ole Miss in yards, 613-253.
The one that mattered most though? I was shocked at how poorly the Buccaneers played last week on both sides of the ball. The Buccaneers and the New Orleans Saints have two, while the Atlanta Falcons and Carolina Panthers are 3-1.
CSKA Moscow were victims of another Lukaku-Martial combination for the second goal as the Belgian fed off of Martial's cross. Manchester United can not rest Romelu Lukaku until Zlatan Ibrahimovic is back fit and available, manager Jose Mourinho said.
The forecast is for warm, dry days so the decision at the toss will be surely working in the favor of team who will win the toss . However, Rohit exclaimed how he relished the opportunity to bat alongside his Mumbai batsman Ajinkya Rahane .
He destroyed a game two years ago with five sacks and a safety, and hassled Broncos quarterback Trevor Siemian on Sunday. With Manuel leading a drive, the Raiders drove to a field goal, pulling within 16-10 with 5:23 left to play.
It's no wonder Barcelona were prepared to make him the club's most expensive signing in their history. "You don't listen to them". Benitez remains relaxed over his future at Newcastle amid speculation that the club wants to tie him down with a new contract.
Roughly 5.3 million people were eligible to vote, and most of the region's 948 municipalities agreed to provide voting facilities. The Spanish prime minister, Mariano Rajoy , speaking on Sunday night, thanked the police for acting with "firmness and serenity".
AT&T has confirmed that it will be selling the iPhone X, and pre-orders begin on October 27 with availability starting November 3. Thanks Zing Gadget for loaning us the iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus for this hands on! Update: Added pricing details for AT&T .
If they can get even a modicum of production on offense, getting Carson Palmer under pressure will be the key. Both of these teams have struggled to get their opponents offenses off of the field on 3rd down this year.
People expected this young Yankees team (which still has more significant talent on the way from AAA) to start competing in 2018. Taking into account a few articles and odds listings that are already out there, here’s our look at the top contenders. 1.
When asked about the gunman's motive, Sheriff Joseph Lombardo said he could not "get into the mind of a psychopath at this point". Sisolak also started an online fundraising effort for the victims that by Tuesday had brought in $2.7 million from 38,000 donors.
The band released its third album " Damn the Torpedoes " in 1979 which included the breakthrough hit "Refugee". Maybe he soundtracked your little league games, your first time getting high, your freshman year of college.
Latest News on the Global Online Gaming Industry
The company is showing signs of making a comeback, as competitors are forced to merge and consolidate in order to survive. The industry can be broken down further between mobile gambling and desktop gambling (which includes laptops and PCs).
Equifax to offer free credit freezes for life, new CEO claims
Equifax says that, after the intrusion, data appeared to have been stolen in May, but the theft wasn't discovered until late July. Smith said he was informed of the breach the next day, and Equifax started taking action in response to the breach on August 2.
One big question mark hangs over Twins' wild-card lineup
The 23-year-old righthander, who made his first All-Star team , allowed no more than one run in an MLB-best 16 of his 31 starts. In his first full Major League Baseball season, Judge is already conditioned in the Yankees' October-or-bust reality.
Vegas Play of the Day: Washington at Kansas City
Washington Redskins travel to Kansas City to take on the Chiefs in Week Four's Monday Night Football action, live on Sky Sports. CB Josh Norman went out of the game with a rib fracture and safety Montae Nicholson is now dealing with an AC joint sprain.
San Juan mayor says Trump is 'looking for an excuse'
After visiting the island on Monday he came away thinking that an organized supply chain was the island's most vital need. But the mayor of San Juan, Puerto Rico's capital, hit back at stories about how well the relief efforts are going.
Jets say it's time to start respecting them
After rising from the turf, Ealy chucked the ball into the stands behind the end zone in celebration before running off the field. The Jaguars were without defensive end Lerentee McCray (knee) and wide receiver Jaelen Strong (hamstring) due to injuries.
Alexis Sanchez attitude the key to Arsenal's season?
A win for Eagles on ten points will effectively seal qualification to Russian Federation 2018 for Nigeria with one game to spare. An outstanding pass from Alexis Sanchez cued Iwobi up for the second goal, snapping a second half lull.